Held to Account

Home › Council tax

Council tax tribunal toolkit

Last checked 10 November 2026

Your proposal has been refused and you're appealing to the Valuation Tribunal. This toolkit gives you the deadlines, the tactics and the letters, and assumes the Valuation Office will hold back everything it can.

Test version. The toolkit is free while it's being tested. It will cost £19.99 once testing is finished.

Starting the appeal

1 Your deadlines

Enter the dates you have. The deadlines appear as you type.

The tribunal aims to list appeals within five months of registering them and to give 10 to 12 weeks' notice of the hearing. The exact deadlines are in the directions sent with your notice of hearing. If they differ from these, follow the directions.

2 How the evidence is exchanged

  1. At least six weeks before the hearing, the Valuation Office must send you its full case and its evidence.
  2. At least four weeks before the hearing, you send the Valuation Office your reply and any further evidence. The tribunal won't look at evidence you haven't sent, unless it's new.
  3. At least two weeks before the hearing, the Valuation Office sends both cases to you and the tribunal in one bundle.
  4. The hearing is usually by video or phone on Microsoft Teams and lasts about an hour to an hour and a half. You normally go first. Hearings are open to the public.

3 Your right to see the sales evidence

Sale prices from 1991 come from records the Valuation Office holds but you can't see. The tribunal's rules, in regulation 17 of the Valuation Tribunal for England (Council Tax and Rating Appeals) (Procedure) Regulations 2009, control how it uses them:

You can't get this information before you appeal. The Valuation Office says the law stops it sharing information about other properties at the challenge stage, and Freedom of Information requests have been refused for the same reason.

4 Tactics

This is the part that wins or loses appeals. Assume the Valuation Office knows the system and will use it.

  1. Your best evidence goes in at the start. Holding evidence back for the hearing doesn't work: the panel won't look at evidence you didn't send, unless it's new. A strong case can also be settled before it ever reaches a hearing.
  2. Enforce the timetable. If the Valuation Office's full case hasn't arrived six weeks before the hearing, write to the tribunal that day. Don't wait.
  3. Serve your sales notice the day theirs arrives. Name homes you suspect sold low around 1991, such as identical homes in a lower band, or homes in your own street. You don't need to know their prices. The Valuation Office has to produce what it holds.
  4. Take their comparables apart, one by one. For each: is it the same type, age, design and size? Is it in the same street or estate? Was the sale near 1 April 1991? Was it an ordinary open-market sale, or a repossession, a family sale, a part exchange or a right-to-buy sale? Had it been extended or freshly modernised when it sold?
  5. Object to anything late. If sales evidence turns up without the two weeks' notice, or anything new appears after the deadlines or at the hearing, object in writing and ask the panel to exclude it.
  6. Keep to value on 1 April 1991. Don't follow the Valuation Office into condition, repair against improvement, today's prices or anything else that doesn't decide the band.
  7. Use reasonable repair both ways. The law assumes every home is in reasonable repair. A comparable that sold freshly modernised in 1991 sold for more than one in reasonable repair would have.

5 Your letters

Fill in your details once and they go into every letter. Your details stay on this device.

Letter A: asking for the full case

Send to the Valuation Office when your notice of hearing arrives.

Letter B: naming homes for the sales evidence

Send to the Valuation Office the day its notice of sales evidence arrives.

Letter C: to the tribunal if the Valuation Office is late or won't comply

Send to the tribunal, copied to the Valuation Office, the day a deadline is missed.

Letter D: objecting to late or new evidence

Send to the tribunal and the Valuation Office as soon as you see it, and repeat the objection at the start of the hearing.

Your reply to the Valuation Office's case

Send to the Valuation Office at least four weeks before the hearing. Fill in one section for each of its comparables.

6 At the hearing

The tribunal's decision is final on the facts. An appeal to the High Court is possible only on a point of law.

Sources

See also: Should I challenge my council tax band? and Should I challenge? (the check).